Skip to content
Back to the daily read

Daily Read: Sports & Health

How to Break the Silence After a Fight

Relationship expert Bonnie King explains that silence after a disagreement can signal overwhelm, punishment, or a healthy break. She distinguishes three patterns: shutting down, stonewalling, and the silent treatment used as control. Shutting down often occurs when a person feels unsafe speaking and is usually followed by a desire to reconnect. Stonewalling, driven by emotional flooding, leaves the other partner feeling abandoned. The silent treatment, King says, is intentional withdrawal to make the partner feel guilty and can become a form of control if repeated. When a partner needs a break, King recommends setting a clear time to resume the conversation, such as saying, “I need an hour, then I want to finish this.” After expressing this, she advises stepping back and focusing on self‑care until both parties are calm. Once calm, the discussion can shift from “what did we fight about?” to “how can we handle future arguments?” King warns that repeated use of silence to force apologies signals a deeper issue that should be addressed seriously.

· Upworthy

The essential points

  1. 01Shutting down is often a response to feeling unsafe speaking, and usually leads to a desire to reconnect.
  2. 02Stonewalling, driven by emotional flooding, leaves partners feeling abandoned and rejected.
  3. 03The silent treatment is intentional withdrawal to punish, and repeated use can become a form of control.
  4. 04A healthy break involves setting a clear return time, e.g., saying, “I need an hour, then I want to finish this.”
The full brief

Relationship expert Bonnie King explains that silence after a disagreement can signal overwhelm, punishment, or a healthy break. She distinguishes three patterns: shutting down, stonewalling, and the silent treatment used as control. Shutting down often occurs when a person feels unsafe speaking and is usually followed by a desire to reconnect. Stonewalling, driven by emotional flooding, leaves the other partner feeling abandoned.

The silent treatment, King says, is intentional withdrawal to make the partner feel guilty and can become a form of control if repeated. When a partner needs a break, King recommends setting a clear time to resume the conversation, such as saying, “I need an hour, then I want to finish this.” After expressing this, she advises stepping back and focusing on self‑care until both parties are calm. Once calm, the discussion can shift from “what did we fight about?”

to “how can we handle future arguments?” King warns that repeated use of silence to force apologies signals a deeper issue that should be addressed seriously.